Couple Imprisoned After Raising $400K For Homeless Veteran In GoFundMe Trick

Most of the time, GoFundMe fundraisers are used for helping those in need; other times, people abuse the kindness of others to use the money for themselves.

Unfortunately, this is a story about one of those scams.

Story Time!

Slide
NBC News
NBC News

This story revolves around a couple, Katelyn McClure and her ex-boyfriend, Mark D’Amico.

The pair created a fundraiser in 2017 for a homeless veteran, Johnny Bobbitt Jr., who had helped Katelyn with a problem.

ADVERTISEMENT

Out of Gas

ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-erik-mclean-9216590
Photo by Erik Mclean/pexels
Photo by Erik Mclean/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

What was the problem?

ADVERTISEMENT

Back in 2017, Katelyn’s car ran out of gas on I-95 near Philadelphia, and Johnny gave Katelyn his only $20 so she could fill her car up on gas.

ADVERTISEMENT

Katelyn's Generosity

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-said-photographer-12273873
Photo by Said Photographer/pexels
Photo by Said Photographer/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Afterward, Katelyn said she repaid him for the gas and would stop by his spot occasionally.

ADVERTISEMENT

She also gave him a jacket, gloves, other warm clothes, and some extra cash.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Generosity of Thousands

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-dio-hasbi-saniskoro-3280130
Photo by Dio Hasbi Saniskoro/pexels
Photo by Dio Hasbi Saniskoro/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Then she set up a GoFundMe account. Katelyn’s initial goal for the fundraiser was to raise $10,000 for Johnny to help him find an apartment, a vehicle and four to six months of expenses.

ADVERTISEMENT

But thanks to the generosity of over 14,000 people, Katelyn surpassed her goal.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Roof Over His Head

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-pixabay-277787
Photo by Pixabay/pexels
Photo by Pixabay/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

And as a cherry on top, Katelyn showed more of her generosity by taking him shopping over Thanksgiving weekend and putting Johnny up in a hotel - finally a roof over his head!

ADVERTISEMENT

What a kind and generous person!

ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny's Life Was Forever Changed

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-pixabay-34534
Photo by Pixabay/pexels
Photo by Pixabay/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny “couldn't sleep” because he was so thankful for the generosity of so many people on GoFundMe.

ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny was so humble and said that "his life had been changed" when only $1,700 had been raised.

ADVERTISEMENT

More People Wanted To Help!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-anna-tarazevich-5697255
Photo by Anna Tarazevich/pexels
Photo by Anna Tarazevich/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

And when the fundraiser made more than $100,000, he asked that it be taken down.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, Katelyn put it back up because so many people were interested in helping Johnny!

ADVERTISEMENT

It Was What Now!?

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-andrea-piacquadio-3784324
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio/pexels
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Such a heartwarming story; it could bring a tear to your eye. And it will because it was all A LIE!

ADVERTISEMENT

In November 2018, all three people were charged with second-degree theft by deception.

ADVERTISEMENT

They Met At A Casino

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-darya-sannikova-2422398
Photo by Darya Sannikova/pexels
Photo by Darya Sannikova/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

In fact, Katelyn and Mark knew Johnny because they ran into him several times on their way to the casino.

ADVERTISEMENT

Katelyn approached and befriended Johnny, and over time, the three of them planned everything out.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Story of LIES!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-andrea-piacquadio-3808904
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio/pexels
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

That’s right! The three of them made up the entire story to trick people into donating money.

ADVERTISEMENT

How do we know it’s a lie? Because there were several mistakes along the way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mistake #1

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-kaboompics-com-6111
Photo by Kaboompics.com/pexels
Photo by Kaboompics.com/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

The first mistake was made by Katelyn McClure. An hour after the GoFundMe went live, McClure texted her friend,

ADVERTISEMENT

“Okay, so wait, the gas part is completely made up… But the guy isn’t… I had to make something up to make people feel bad… So, shush about the made-up part.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Greed Was Their Downfall

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-karolina-grabowska-4968668
Photo by Karolina Grabowska/pexels
Photo by Karolina Grabowska/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

The next mistake was Katelyn and Mark’s greed.

ADVERTISEMENT

They had come up with this whole plan and were going to give Johnny a cut of the fundraiser money - but didn’t.

ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny's Lawsuit

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-mikhail-nilov-8729815
Photo by Mikhail Nilov/pexels
Photo by Mikhail Nilov/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Because he had not seen any of the money yet, Johnny filed a lawsuit against the couple.

ADVERTISEMENT

The lawsuit claimed the couple mismanaged the donations and used the money for personal luxurious goods.

ADVERTISEMENT

Look Here Comes The Consequence

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-martin-lopez-2157191
Photo by Martin Lopez/pexels
Photo by Martin Lopez/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Actually, this very public lawsuit was the reason the fundraiser was looked into.

ADVERTISEMENT

Investigators looked into the fundraiser and found all the incriminating information they needed to arrest the three co-conspirators for theft.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mark's Sentence

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-jimmy-chan-1309902
Photo by Jimmy Chan/pexels
Photo by Jimmy Chan/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Mark D’Amico, considered the ringleader of the scam, pleaded guilty to mishandling the money from the GoFundMe fundraiser.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mark was sentenced to 27 months in prison in April 2022 and faces state charges in September 2022.

ADVERTISEMENT

Katelyn's Sentence

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-rodnae-productions-6064890
Photo by RODNAE Productions/pexels
Photo by RODNAE Productions/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Katelyn McClure, the face of the scam, also pleaded guilty and is looking at one year in prison and serving three years of supervised release.

ADVERTISEMENT

She also faces state charges in September 2022.

ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny's Sentence

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pexels-towfiqu-barbhuiya-8693379
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya/pexels
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya/pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

Johnny Bobbitt Jr., the man people wanted to help, faced state charges and was sentenced to probation for five years in 2019.

ADVERTISEMENT

He also faces sentencing in September 2022 for federal charges against him.